[Oberon] The Oberon answer to Arduino

peasthope at shaw.ca peasthope at shaw.ca
Wed Dec 26 20:43:43 CET 2012


I admire your enthusiasm and effort; so don't take 
this as criticism.  

A collaborative or community project needs much more 
"argument" before participants are convinced of a course 
of action.  Inevitably some egos will be threatened 
or offended; some participants you might hope for, will 
take their toys and go home.

From:	<Aubrey.McIntosh at Alumni.UTexas.Net>
Date:	Mon, 24 Dec 2012 16:29:25 -0600
> ... the PIC folks are saying
> that the libraries are closed and have some critical design bugs and they
> want an architecture where you can control stuff down to the bits.

Such as the XO?  It's a complete machine including advanced 
Open Firmware to help with startup and debugging, good 
wireless and a display which can be read in broad daylight as 
well as in usual cave conditions.

> At one level, my project is about a teaching tool. 

Precisely what OLPC is about!  Of course that doesn't preclude 
other purposes.

> So this brings to mind the question, should I go with a MIPS processor?
>  They are available for about $5 each, ...

Whereas in G1G1 the XO is $400 and on eBay about $120.  

Apparently the policy in Uruguay is for every primary school 
child to have one.  If Uruguayans can afford them, maybe  
people in industrialized countries can too.

The difference between $5 and $400 or $120 is easily justified 
when you allow for the XO being a well designed complete 
machine with completely open specs; and allow that the cost 
of software surpasses the cost of hardware by orders orders of 

> I'd love to see a community project come together.

Many of us agree; but a big obstacle is that people are still pulling 
in too many directions.  To solve this we need to find a consensus 
of focus.  First make a list of candidate hardwares.  Then evaluate 
the pros and cons of each.  Then decide an acceptable compromise.
Then try to move it forward.

Best Regards,                 ... Peter E.

123456789 123456789 123456789 123456789 123456789 123456789 123456789 12
Tel +13606390202  Bcc: peasthope at shaw.ca  http://carnot.yi.org/  
"http://members.shaw.ca/peasthope/index.html#Itinerary "

More information about the Oberon mailing list